Despite Jane having much experience
teaching, her experience with technology is not on par. Since technology such
as wiki has barely starting when she became a teacher. Now Jane is overwhelmed
herself because she does not know how she can help the students do the equal
amount of work. I think what Jane is missing is that she needs to monitor the
groups more frequently. The way you can do this, is by always asking questions
such as how things are going, and what problems have they come up in the middle
of the lesson, as well as create a discussion to see how the other groups are
doing. This will help because the students will se how the other groups are
doing, and will encourage them to do better. I think they need to feel a
certain level of competition so they can get things done. Also one thing that
isn’t mentioned but is rather important is the group sizes. I think that using
Wiki sites at 6th grade is too much for 12-year-old students. I
think that the reason they are having issues is that some students feel
comfortable using wiki and the others don’t. This would explain how she found
only one student working on wiki and the rest of the group was not making any
cooperation. If wiki is to be used in
this grade level, the instructor needs to lead the classroom, as well as make
the groups with 2 people only. This will ensure that the students stay focused
and are less pressured by other students in the group. I think that the teacher
will be able to instruct the students if they are in a group of two. Using wiki
can help the teacher understand how well the class is going. I think that it is
amazing how she realized the classroom groups were not at the same level, and
that how different each group was working. The issue is now to fine tune where
the students are doing wrong and maybe by simply changing up the teams you can
have better results. I think that despite my opinion that Wiki being too much
for a sixth grade class, I think that good results can still come from it. The
children in my opinion are doing whatever they please because the instructor is
not engaging with the students as much as it is needed. The students need to
see the instructor approach the students so that they can see where they are
doing right and wrong. I don’t think the
teacher should feel disappointed on her findings, she simply should gather the
findings and work into making improvements from there. Being a sixth grade
class she should be very proud that even some of the students are able to use
wiki, now what I would do is have those that know how to use it work with the
students that struggled, and those that made the presentation look “pretty”
integrate them in the groups that were accurate so they could make the wiki presentations
look professional.
Edna, I like how you mentioned that Jane needs to be more involved with what the students are doing. You're right about her needing to monitor what the students are doing. There are times that some teachers assign a technology project without monitoring, and then when the final product is turned in they are disappointed with the quality of the work. Good advice.
ReplyDeleteEdna, I agree that the teacher would be more successful and have less problems if she monitored the students progress. I think if she learned more tools and techniques to work with the program that could also help some of the frustrations she is having. I think wiki is a good program for students to use to work collaboratively together.
ReplyDeleteGreat post!
Edna,
ReplyDeleteI agree with what you mentioned about obtaining great results from the students even though it seems like the assignment about the science research might not have started on a good foot. Students always come through with shining colors even at their age of 6th grade. Students need to be constantly monitored and given explanations and samples of what Jane is expecting. I think Jane should focus on the finished projects the students will turn in. Since this is Jane's first encounter with using wikis herself, the learning experience will be a memorable one and now Jane will know what to expect with future projects.